Friday, November 20, 2026 For licensed Medicare agents and brokers Subscribe
The Commission Financial intelligence for Medicare agents
Latest tracked changes
All changes →

Carriers

UnitedHealthcare’s 390,000 non-renewals: what agents should do, and what they’ll be paid

About 390,000 UnitedHealthcare members got non-renewal letters dated Oct. 2. Moving them to another Medicare Advantage plan usually pays the renewal rate, not the initial rate.

UnitedHealthcare is discontinuing Medicare Advantage plans that cover about 390,000 members for 2027, and the non-renewal letters are dated October 2. Those clients need new coverage. But if you move them into another Medicare Advantage plan, you will usually be paid the renewal rate, not the initial rate. Plan the season around that.

What’s happening

A UnitedHealth spokesperson confirmed that approximately 390,000 members are in plans being discontinued. Together with Humana’s exits, more than one million seniors will have to change plans for 2027.

UnitedHealthcare’s own provider notice says the service-area reductions and plan discontinuations take effect January 1, 2027, and that affected members will receive non-renewal notices dated October 2, 2026. The company has not published a list of the affected plans or counties. Its provider FAQ says only that the affected plans “can vary by state and county.”

Two markets have been reported. UnitedHealthcare is dropping some Minnesota plans and about a dozen Minnesota counties, affecting 14,500 people, and is leaving Wyoming’s Medicare Advantage market entirely, according to BenefitsUSA, citing Forbes. UnitedHealthcare has not confirmed those details to The Commission.

Your clients’ deadlines

  • October 15 to December 31, 2026: Affected members can enroll in another Medicare Advantage plan for a January 1, 2027 start, according to UnitedHealthcare’s FAQ.
  • January 1, 2027: Members who do nothing go back to Original Medicare automatically.
  • Through February 28, 2027: Members who end up in Original Medicare have a special election period to choose a new Medicare Advantage plan.
  • Drug coverage: If the discontinued plan included Part D, that drug coverage ends too. Original Medicare does not include drug coverage, and going 63 days or more without creditable coverage can trigger a late enrollment penalty, BenefitsUSA notes.
  • Medigap: Members whose plan is ending get a guaranteed-issue right to buy certain Medigap policies if they switch to Original Medicare. They must apply no later than 63 days after their Medicare Advantage coverage ends. Tell clients to keep the non-renewal letter and its envelope as proof.

What you will be paid

Under CMS rules, agents are paid an initial commission in a member’s first year, or when the member makes an “unlike plan type” change. When a member renews or makes a “like plan type” change, compensation is up to half as much. A move from one Medicare Advantage plan to another is a like plan type change, even when the client switches carriers.

For 2027 that means a capped renewal of $363 in most states, against a $725 initial cap. Moving a displaced UnitedHealthcare client into a new Medicare Advantage plan keeps the client and the renewal stream. It is usually not a new initial commission. The exception is a client still in their first year of Medicare Advantage, where CMS requires pro-rated initial-year pay under 42 CFR 422.2274.

Pay on the replacement plan is also not guaranteed. Several carriers are paying nothing on new enrollments into some 2027 plans, including Aetna on 123 plans in 33 states. Check the replacement plan’s status on your carrier schedule before the appointment.

Your move

  1. Pull every UnitedHealthcare member in your book. When the non-renewal letters arrive, ask clients to send you a photo of theirs; it is the fastest way to confirm who is affected.
  2. Prioritize clients with Part D through their current plan. A gap in drug coverage costs them money and can trigger a lifetime penalty.
  3. For each client, compare a replacement Medicare Advantage plan with Original Medicare plus Medigap and a standalone drug plan. The Medigap guaranteed-issue window only applies if they leave Medicare Advantage.
  4. Confirm the replacement plan is commissionable and note whether it pays initial or renewal rate for that client. Recommend on suitability, not pay.
  5. Book appointments for October 15 onward now. Enrolling early also protects clients from plans that close when they hit an enrollment cap.

Have UnitedHealthcare’s list of discontinued plans or counties for your market? Submit it for editorial review → Remove client and agent details first.

More from The Commission